Trans-Fee Mining Exchanges Have Poor Traffic to Volume Ratios, yet Their Market Share Is Rising

Cryptocurrency exchanges using the trans-fee mining (TFM) revenue model have, according to available data, poor traffic to volume ratios, meaning a small number of traders see large amounts of crypto change hands on their platforms. Despite using incentivized trading schemes to generate 'fake volume' these exchanges have grown their market share.

According to CryptoCompare’s January 2019 Exchange Review, cryptocurrency exchanges using the controversial mining model have grown to represent 15% of the crypto ecosystem’s trading volume, up from 12%. In January alone they traded $25 billion worth of crypto in the first month of the year.

The number one trans-fee mining exchange was CoinBene, which by itself traded $10 billion. It was followed by ZBG, which traded $6 billion, and by EXX, which traded $5.5 billion. These platforms’ trading volumes have grown, although overall crypto exchange traffic went down.

Per the report, traffic notably dropped 13.5% in January, with spot trading volumes accompanying it with a 12.4% drop. The total amount of unique visitors cryptocurrency exchanges received in January was 10.4 million, down from 12 million in December.

Crypto exchanges' volumes and traffic in January of 2019Source: CryptoCompare Research

While their trading volumes are high (red for TFM exchanges), the amount of traffic their platforms see is noticeably low. Traders on these platforms are incentivized by the revenue model to trade large amounts, in order to be rewarded in tokens.

The controversial revenue model was initially introduced by FCoin, which managed to see an over $5 billion daily trading volume at the time thanks to it. Some called it a “disguised ICO” over its nature. Its incentives may be questionable, as CryptoCompare’s report puts it, grouping it to zero-fee exchanges:

Transaction fee mining exchanges rebate 100% of transition fees in the form of their own exchange tokens. This might give traders an incentive to trade more to receive more tokens which often have valuable features such as voting rights on the platform or a dividend. Both of the above can lead to wash trading.

Although these crypto exchanges have large trading volumes, this doesn’t mean their order books are secure. CryptoCompare analysis from October showed that on TFM exchanges it would take a very small amount of their daily trading volume to see prices drop 10% on their platform.

Specifically, an analysis of CoinBene’s order books showed it would take just 0.3% of its trading volume to see the price of a crypto drop 10% on it. In comparison, it would take over 30% of the daily trading volume exchanges like Kraken and Bitstamp see to see prices drop 10% showing much greater stability in the more established and trusted exchanges.

Bitbond CEO Radoslav Albrecht Talks STOs, ICOs and Crypto Mass Adoption

Bitbond

One of the interesting applications of crypto and blockchain technology that is seeing actual use is business lending.

Bitbond is a company that offers business loans to small and medium-sized businesses using crypto. Based in Germany, Bitbond aims to tap into the enormous SME lending market, and sees blockchain as the means to do it.

We spoke with CEO Radoslav Albrecht about Bitbond, the future of STOs and ICOs, the regulatory landscape in Germany and what he thinks will pave the way for mass crypto adoption.

When did you get interested in crypto?

A good friend told me about Bitcoin in 2012, however, I didn't get into crypto until about a year later when I was researching efficient cross border payments.

What led you to create Bitbond?

As a consultant at Roland Berger, I was exposed to many different banking projects and quickly learned how inefficient lending processes were in the industry. This made me realise that there was huge potential for a platform like Bitbond that could automate much of the process while also reaching SMEs all over the world. Today we’re proud to provide financing in under 30 minutes making Bitbond perhaps the fastest way for a business to receive capital.

How do loans work via Bitbond?

Business owners apply for a loan through our borrower application. The application process is very simple. Entrepreneurs provide basic information about their business via an intuitive online application. This takes about 15 minutes and is done exclusively online.

Bitbond focuses on online / e-commerce sellers.  Businesses in this space typically sell on eBay, Amazon, Etsy, Shopify and many other large platforms. These have great APIs which we connect with in order to learn as much as possible about the health of the business.

Not only does this approach allow us to assess the creditworthiness of an SME very reliably, but it allows us to do our credit scoring very quickly. So if a borrower is approved he/she can receive funding in 24hrs after their application.

In terms of the technical side, we leverage blockchain technology for efficient cross-border payment processing and developed our own machine learning powered credit scoring algorithm.

What distinguishes Bitbond from other blockchain lending platforms?

Bitbond targets small business owners and aims to fill the 2 trillion dollar funding gap for SMEs.

Also, Bitbond is the first lending platform to service SMEs globally. This is great because we have a huge addressable market as a company. At the same time, we reach many business owners in remote locations who otherwise wouldn’t have access to capital. In order to make this happen, we need an efficient way to send money across borders.

When we launched Bitbond in 2013 we started by using bitcoin for payment processing. Today we primarily rely on EUR-denominated tokens that are issued on the Stellar blockchain. Stellar is more scalable and more cost efficient for our use case than bitcoin and by using the EURT we eliminate all foreign exchange risk versus the Euro.

Do you think “STOs” are the new “ICO”: Is the ICO model something you think the industry should move away from?

I think in the long run there is a place for both ICOs  and STOs. Crypto started with this anarchistic, decentralised community that was strongly influenced by the Cypherpunk community. STOs move away from this mentality and are a more regulated and less decentralised version, however, it is not a fundamental change in the industry and as I believe there is a place for both.

The ICO wave may have subsided but I believe it will return alongside STOs, both of these types of token sales just add to the innovation and diversity of the crypto landscape. Overall I feel STOs are complementary and not a replacement for ICOs and together they will push innovation in the blockchain space.

Do you think the mad bull run of 2017 and subsequent crash was a net positive or a net negative for the industry?​​​​​​

The bull run did an incredible job of introducing crypto to the mainstream. For example, recent studies show that 50% of American millennials are now interested in using crypto and millions of people own at least one type of coin.

Of course, the crash had a negative impact on the industry in the short term, but it also provided an important learning opportunity for entrepreneurs and investors who believed that prices would just keep going up.

Finally, I would say that crashes are inevitable in almost any industry, but it’s the recovery that is important. In the case of crypto, we’re now seeing much healthier growth and I would say that the bull run was a net positive as a result.

What obstacles do you see ahead before we can reach mass crypto adoption?

Crypto/blockchain is primarily an infrastructure technology, like Linux. Therefore it entirely depends on the use-cases that entrepreneurs and businesses develop on top of it. There are many excellent examples of tokens which have the potential to be used by the mainstream. I think our BB1 token is one example, and Brave’s BAT is another.

That being said there are some clear challenges ahead. The first one regards scalability and is probably the oldest problem in the blockchain industry. Bitcoin, Ethereum and many other popular tokens do not have the capacity to process a large volume of transactions. For the BB1 token, we chose Stellar which can reportedly process around 4,000 transactions per second - far more than the 7 that Bitcoin manages. Nevertheless, mainstream adoption would require closer to 40,000 transactions per second, so we still have work ahead of us.

Another important issue I’d like to touch on is usability. At Bitbond we’ve put a lot of time and effort into making our service as simple as possible. As crypto-natives it’s easy to forget how intimidating the jargon and hexadecimal strings can be to a beginner. In order to achieve adoption, we need to make the process of buying, selling and using crypto as intuitive as possible.

As a crypto company based in Germany, what’s your opinion of the German regulatory landscape?

Bitbond was the first BaFin regulated blockchain company in Germany. We received our licence in October 2016 and have been in continuous communication with the regulator since then.

We’ve been impressed with BaFin’s openness to new technology and have benefited from the guidance they have provided. The fact that our security prospectus was approved is a very encouraging sign to other crypto companies looking at alternative forms of fundraising.

With that in mind, I believe that the regulatory landscape is already good and getting better in Germany due to a high level of awareness about the space with lawmakers.

What’s on your roadmap for the rest of 2019?

Our goal is to make fast and affordable capital available to SMEs all over the world. Our STO will not only help us achieve this goal, but will also open up attractive interest rates to both retail and institutional lenders.

With regards to our roadmap for 2019, the first important step is the successful conclusion of our STO. Then we will begin paying BB1 holders on a quarterly and annual basis. Importantly, the Bitbond STO concludes in July, meaning that your readers need to act fast in order to receive payouts.

As a special offer, we’d like to share a unique discount code for CryptoGlobe readers. To receive a 5% discount, simply enter CC5BB1 during the checkout process. Do bear in mind the code is valid until the end of May.

The raised funds will be reinvested into SMEs all over the world. That means that BB1 holders not only receive smart passive income, but they also improve the lives of entrepreneurs living in some of the most disenfranchised places on earth.

The majority of the funds raised in the Bitbond STO are going towards funding loans originated on our platform. Some funds are being invested in activities such as growth and marketing to allow for Bitbond to reach more SMEs and fund more loans on Bitbond. This will help Bitbond increase its global presence and allow Bitbond to provide funding SMEs on a larger scale.

Therefore the funds raised in the STO will greatly determine our roadmap for 2019. However, the main goal is to scale up Bitbond and provide funding to more small businesses while giving our investors great stable and secure returns.

Stable and secure returns are uncommon terms in the token sale landscape. But this is where we think the Bitbond Security token offering can differentiate from other tokens as it can provide a real security based asset comparable to a bond, that anyone can invest in and be an investment that can be counted on to add to investors passive income year on year.

If you would like to ask me more questions about Bitbond and our STO,  we are hosting a live webinar with a question and answer session on Monday, 27th of May at 7 pm (CET). To join our webinar click this link.