Bitcoin ETF Frenzy Sees Letters Flood the SEC's Inbox

  • A Bitcoin ETF may be just around the corner, as crypto supporters have been flooding the SEC's inbox with supporting comments.
  • A notable letter sent to the regulator even argues the ETF would be in line with its goals of protecting investors.

A Bitcoin ETF may be just around the corner. Recently, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has been flooded with comments that mostly support the financial product’s approval, while attempting to clarify why it would be positive.

Last month, Cboe Global Markets, an exchange already trading bitcoin futures contracts, filed an application with the SEC for the approval of a Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF). After filing the application, Cboe invited the public to comment on the matter.

Simply put, an Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is a product designed to track the performance of an underlying asset. ETFs grant investors indirect ownership of an asset, in this case Bitcoin, and can have several advantages, including higher liquidity and investor protections.

So far, the SEC has received over 90 comments from cryptocurrency supporters telling the regulator they would like to be able to invest in the flagship cryptocurrency through traditional, regulated markets without having to choose bitcoin futures.

According to Bloomberg, Cboe’s application got roughly ten times more comments than a previous Bitcoin ETF application the regulator received back in April. Along with these comments, users have been emailing the SEC letters supporting the move and flooding other areas of its website.

One notable letter came from Morgan Creek Digital Assets. The letter, shared by the firm’s founder Anthony Pompliano, notes that “the citizens of the United States are interested in purchasing, holding, and transacting Bitcoin.”

Per the letter, a Bitcoin ETF would be in line with the SEC’s goals to protect investors. It reads:

Your stated mandate as an independent agency of the US federal government is to “protect investors; maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets; and facilitate capital formation.” The approval of a Bitcoin ETF would accomplish these goals.

Morgan Creek Digital

The ETF, it adds, will give users a secure way to buy and sell the flagship cryptocurrency while granting them the protections of an ETF, including “insurance and institutional-grade custody.” The firm’s letter notes that BTC, just like the US dollar, gets its value from people’s belief, meaning it has value because people believe it does.

Given one BTC is trading at $7,460, the “millions of Americans who believe in Bitcoin’s value” should be able to invest in a product that’ll protect them against some of the cryptocurrency ecosystem’s pitfalls, it argues.

Despite the mostly positive comments and letters the SEC has received, there are those who disapprove of a Bitcoin ETF, arguing that such a financial product is “worrisome” because of “ongoing anomalies” in the cryptocurrency’s price. Specifically, the ETF’s opponents believe BTC’s price is being manipulated.

Notably, regulatory developments may mean we’re as close as we’ve ever been to seeing a Bitcoin ETF. As CryptoGlobe covered, SEC chairman Jay Clayton recently revealed decentralized cryptocurrencies like bitcoin and ethereum aren’t securities.

Cboe Global Markets launched bitcoin futures contracts in the US back in December of last year, when most cryptocurrencies were at their all-time high. Its current Bitcoin ETF application will limit trading to SolidX Bitcoin Shares, with one share being worth 25 BTC.

If the application is approved, trading is scheduled to start in Q1 2019. Various applications have been turned down by the SEC, with a notable one come from the Winklevoss Twins’ Gemini exchange, which recently hired a former NYSE CIO.

Notable Bitcoin Trader and Whale Not Bullish on the Hyperinflation Narrative

Colin Muller

Highly regarded Bitfinex trader and crypto whale J0E007 is not banking on the hyperinflation narrative, which is a highly popular notion in the cryptoasset industry, implying it's a fairy tale.

Screenshot from 2020-05-26 13-23-22.png(source: Bitfinex pulse)

This narrative, exhibited for example here, proposes that the aggressive fiscal and monetary intervention on the part of many central banks around the world will eventually lead to sharp devaluations in the values of many fiat currencies—and most importantly of the U.S. dollar.

Propagation of this concept of rampant fiat inflation in the cryptoasset space is generally tied to predictions of a huge increase in the price and/or market capitalization of Bitcoin and other cryptos, although most focus on the flagship cryptocurrency.

A Little More Complicated

In his post, JOE007 linked to a recent report from Alhambra Investments, an asset management and financial research outfit.

The report details lead analyst Jeffrey Snider’s view that the dollar is not going anywhere in terms of demand, although definitely not by virtue of the competence of the U.S. Federal Reserve in handling the unfolding economic crisis lit by COVID-19.

Conceptually, first, any strong desire to hold expensive dollar liquidity buffers is drawn from serious mistrust of systemic conditions – including the central bank’s place in them. If you thought Jay Powell well prepared in advance with effective countermeasures standing at the ready, buffers of any size need not apply.

Jeffrey P. Snider

In short, Snider contends that the Fed under chair Jay Powell has not responded appropriately to the emerging crisis with “effective countermeasures at the ready”; and this bungling in turn has led to a higher international demand for US dollars in order to sit on a larger and safer cushion of “expensive dollar liquidity buffers.”

A complicated subject, to say the least. The upshot for J0E007 being that the dollar-collapsing narrative may have some big holes in it—removing the keystone of that popular Bitcoin use-case narrative.

Featured Image Credit: Photo via